Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Michael Dean's avatar

This was great but the 4/2 entry could use a bit of editing. Kidding. Love this, and also, as you would expect, I disagree. I hope to respond to this sooner or later in detail (and it might even be fun to do some public letters back and forth).

This reminds me of Kerouac’s story; he was disgusted by the idea of editing, and remained unknown for years. On the Road was illegible, until Malcolm Crowley edited it 5 years later. By making it legible, he achieved international fame, and it ended up destroying him. There is a cost and risk of legibility, but that’s a different story I think.

“Editing is violence” is a powerful phrase, and speaks to the strength/disorientation of having your ideas/mind/self rewired. It’s something like an ego death. I personally think it’s valuable which is why I invite people to be as violent as they want with feedback (meaning, Im willing to start again from scratch if you can convince me, but I won’t just agree with anything you say so you’ll like it — I think there’s a stance to be open but extremely skeptical with all external feedback).

I think there a near-spiritual meta-ability in the learning how to detach from mental forms and be open to experience something with truly fresh eyes. Sometime this comes from within, but often it comes from time, weed, or, an editor.

I do agree with you that there’s a petty type of editing where you’re trying to appease a narrow/fleeting market need, but ultimately I think it’s up to the writer to hold their own internal vision for an idea when it makes exposure to a crowd. Maybe it’s not about total isolation/artistry and not about total market conformity/desperation, but as Emerson says, the sweetness of solitude among the madness of crowd.

I just wonder if it’s possible to honor both states: most expression deserves to be untouched, but some ideas are worth treating as a puzzle that you invite your friends to help you solve.

Expand full comment
Kathleen Clare Waller's avatar

Love this metaphor - not just these words but starting with the crying (in Cornwall, no less!!):

“but also the sight of the streaks of water running down the glass, like thoughts that won’t stay, cannot stay, each one making space for the other behind it as if in a chain or a parade in constant motion”

A delicious read, Silvio.

Expand full comment
28 more comments...

No posts